The 1964 Test: Auditing a Library Closure While the Consultation Is Still Open
Photo: delegateconnectimages, CC BY 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons
The pattern is now familiar. A council announces a “library transformation programme”, insists that no decision has been taken, opens a six-week consultation, and simultaneously publishes a cabinet report timetable that ends in a vote. By the time residents have organised, the papers are already written.
You cannot stop that timetable by being angry at it. You can complicate it — with the statute, the numbers and the duty the council owes to the people who use the branch. Here is how to build the case while the consultation is still open.
Start with the statute, not the petition
The Public Libraries and Museums Act 1964 requires every library authority to provide “a comprehensive and efficient library service for all persons desiring to make use of it”. Note the two adjectives. Comprehensive is about reach: who can get to a library, and whether the stock and staff meet what people actually need. Efficient is about how the service is run. A council can save money and still fail the test; it can also fail because nobody in the decision noticed which test they were applying.
The Act gives the Secretary of State a superintendence role and powers to hold an inquiry where an authority appears to be failing. Those powers are used rarely, but the existence of the duty is what gives your submission its spine. In 2011 the Court of Appeal found that Brent council had acted unlawfully in closing libraries without properly applying the 1964 duty. The judgment did not say closures are forbidden. It said the decision-maker must ask the right question and answer it with evidence. That is precisely what your submission should force.
Step one: get the numbers, branch by branch
Ask for the last five years of data for each library: visits, book issues, active borrowers, computer and printing sessions, room bookings, staff hours, opening hours, and the cost of running the building. Ask for the authority-wide totals too, so you can see whether a branch is being described as “underused” in absolute terms while sitting in a ward with no alternative within walking distance.
Compare the council's figures with the national library statistics published annually by CIPFA. If your branch has low issues but high visits, it is probably a digital access and warm-space service — and closing it is a decision about poverty, not about books.
Step two: count the repair backlog
“The building is no longer fit for purpose” is a claim you can test. Request the condition survey, the backlog maintenance figure, any asbestos register, and any RAAC assessment carried out since 2023. Then ask what has been spent on the building over the last decade. A branch with a £600,000 backlog and £4,000 a year of maintenance is not evidence of a failing library; it is evidence of a deferred decision. Say so, in writing, with the figures.
Step three: interrogate the alternative
Most closure plans promise “alternative provision”. Ask exactly what it is: a community-managed library, self-service access, a co-located desk in a leisure centre, a fortnightly mobile stop. Then ask whether the alternative will have paid staff, a stock budget, the same opening hours, step-free access, public toilets and a heating system that works in January.
A room with donated paperbacks and a keypad lock is not a comprehensive service, and the difference matters legally. Put the comparison in a table. Councils find it much harder to wave through a proposal when the substitute is set beside the thing it replaces.
Step four: use the equality duty properly
Section 149 of the Equality Act 2010 requires the council to have due regard to the needs of protected groups before deciding. Library users skew older, poorer and more likely to be digitally excluded. Ask for the equality impact assessment and check three things: whether it existed before the proposal was drafted, whether it contains any actual data about who uses the branch, and whether it records any mitigating action with a budget attached.
Add your own evidence. Which bus route serves the branch? How long is the walk from the nearest estate? How many residents in the ward have no home broadband? A short paragraph with two local statistics will do more than a page of principle.
Step five: test the money
Request the savings calculation. Is it net of redundancy costs, dilapidations, security, business rates and the running costs of the “alternative provision”? Is any capital receipt from selling the building included on both sides of the ledger? Is the building subject to a covenant, a charitable trust deed or a historic gift that restricts disposal? Several Edwardian Carnegie libraries still carry conditions that councils discover only when a developer's solicitor asks.
Step six: check the process against the Gunning principles
The consultation must begin before the decision is taken, be based on adequate information, allow adequate time, and produce responses that are conscientiously taken into account. Look at the cabinet forward plan. If the decision is scheduled for a date before the consultation closes, you have a finding. If the consultation document contains no option to keep the library open, you have another.
Writing the submission
Keep it to 1,000–1,500 words, numbered. Open with what you are asking for — usually that the decision be deferred and the analysis published. Then set out your evidence under four heads: the statutory duty, the usage data, the alternative provision, and the equality impact. Quote the council's own documents back at it, with page numbers. Finish with five specific questions and ask that the answers be published alongside the cabinet report.
Then ask to speak at the meeting. Three minutes is enough if you spend two of them on numbers.
After the deadline
Whatever the outcome, publish your submission and the council's response. If the branch closes, the evidence you gathered becomes the baseline for the next campaign — and for anyone asking, in eighteen months, what the “transformation” actually delivered.